Showing posts with label Guidelines for Overseas NGO Law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Guidelines for Overseas NGO Law. Show all posts

Thursday, December 8, 2016

Foreign Consulates Meet with Public Security officials about the Overseas NGO Law


We are only 24 days away from the Overseas NGO Law going into effect in China, and the only official news we have gotten in the past two months are an October 14 meeting between the Public Security officials with foreign NGOs (mostly business and trade groups) in Shanghai to announce draft Guidelines for the law, a November 8 meeting in Shanghai between Public Security officials and foreign consulates (the subject of this post), and the release of the final official Guidelines.

A summary of the November 8 meeting, the official Guidelines (境外非政府组织代表机构登记和临时活动备案办事指南) in Chinese, and the official English langauge-translation of the Overseas NGO Law are now available on the Ministry of Public Security (MPS) website.  There is so far no official English language translation of the Guidelines, although there is an unofficial translation available on ChinaLawTranslate, and on the WeChat account of FORNGO which bills itself as a center that provides “professional legal services for assisting overseas NGOs with registration of overseas NGO offices, application of filing the record of temporary activities, etc.”.


The remainder of this post is about the November 8 meeting between the MPS and Shanghai PSB and 11 foreign consulates[1] about preparations for the implementation of the Overseas NGO Law.  Several questions were raised at the meeting, particularly (1) whether there would be a "grace period” to give overseas NGOs time to comply with the law, (2) whether NGO representative offices could carry out activities across provinces, and (30 how overseas NGOs with activities in different sectors would determine their professional supervisory units (PSU) or as they are referred to in the Guidelines, business administration departments (BAD).

Before answering these questions, the MPS representative in charge of the Overseas NGO Management office (公安部境外非政府组织管理办公室) made a several statements that were similar to those given at the October 14 meeting.

1) The MPS was giving high-level attention to the work of servicing and managing Overseas NGO and providing efficient and convenient services, and was making intense preparations to ensure that the law would be effectively implemented on January 1, 2017.

2) The coordination mechanism for FNGO supervision and management work had already been established with the MPS and other relevant PSUs participating, to research, coordinate and solve major problems in supervision, management and services for overseas NGOs carrying out activities in China.

3) Provincial Public Security Bureau’s (PSB) Entry/Exit offices were setting up counters for handling registration. In order to provide guidance and help to overseas NGOs seeking to register a representative office or file a record for “temporary activities”, relevant standard documents were being formulated, including the Guidelines for Registration of Overseas NGO Rep Offices and Filing of Records for Temporary Activities 《境外非政府组织代表机构登记和临时活动备案办事指南》, and a Catalogue of Overseas NGO Sectors and Project Areas and Directory of PSUs 《境外非政府组织在中国境内活动领域和项目目录、业务主管单位名录》.

4) An information system and website was being established for overseas NGO management services so that overseas NGOs can go on the website to handle matters and make appointments for registration and filing of records, and apply and submit relevant materials online. Relevant guidance materials would also be published online.

5) The MPS would work together with the Ministry of Civil Affairs (MCA) and State Administration of Industry and Commerce (SAIC) to transfer the registration of those overseas NGO representative offices registered with these two agencies to ensure a smooth transition to the new management framework and protect the legal rights of these overseas NGOs.

This last item refers to the 29 or so overseas NGOs which have managed to register representative offices with the MCA under the 2004 Foundation Management Regulations, and those overseas NGOs that were unable to register representative offices with MCA but were permitted to register representative offices of companies with SAIC.


With regard to the questions posed above, the MPS spokesman provided the following responses.

About the question on the grace period, he replied that "China is a rule of law country, and any laws that go into effect will not have any grace period. When the Overseas NGO Law was passed on April 28, with the aim of going into effect on January 1, 2017, legislative bodies already considered this was a new law and allowed eight months for a preparation period to issue guidelines and catalogues for sectors and projects and a directory of PSUs. He also stated that as soon as the law went into effect, the activities of overseas NGOs and their representatives in mainland China that were registered or recorded would receive legal protection.

Regarding whether overseas NGO representative offices could undertake activities across several provinces, he stated that based on Article 10 and 13 of the Law, FNGOs could set up one or more representative offices in China, and at the time of registration should confirm the geographic area for the activities carried out by that office. A representative office would be allowed to carry out activities across different provinces. For overseas NGO that set up two or more rep offices, the activities of these offices should not overlap or duplicate each other.

Regarding the question of how overseas NGOs that work in different sectors or fields would determine their PSU, he stated that currently they are working on a catalogue of overseas NGO sectors and projects and a directory of PSUs to provide clarification and detail on PSUs in the areas of economy, education, science and tech, culture, health, sports, environmental protection, humanitarian assistance, disaster relief, etc. He noted that “for overseas NGOs working in multiple sectors/fields, the MPS is proposing that overseas NGOs determine its PSU based on their primary or major field of activity. For the overseas NGO's other fields of activity, the main PSU can consult with other relevant departments which should actively cooperate to ensure the management and service work is carried out, and ensure that the overseas NGO is complying with the law in carrying out activities in those issue areas.” 

He did not elaborate on how exactly this proposed arrangement and coordination between the “main PSU” and other relevant departments would work in practice.

In closing, the MPS spokesman emphasized that over the last 30 years of reform and opening, China's economic development and international influence have grown, and overseas NGOs have played a positive role in that process by bringing in projects and funds, diverse ideas, advanced technologies, and valuable experiences. In doing so, they have promoted friendly exchanges between China and other countries, and made a positive contribution to China's economic and social development. China's government continues to welcome and support overseas NGOs to come to China to develop cooperation and exchange programs. The MPS would firmly carry out its work according to the law, carry out its services and management work according to the law, and would work hard to provide assistance and services to overseas NGOs engaged in exchange and cooperation with China.




[1] The U.S., UK, Germany, France, Italy, Japan, Sweden, Netherlands, Poland, Belgium, and Ireland.

Monday, October 17, 2016

Draft Guidelines for the Overseas NGO Law Announced at Shanghai Forum


Last Friday, October 14, the Ministry of Public Security and the Shanghai Municipal Public Security Bureau held a forum in Shanghai for overseas NGOs to announce the draft “Guidelines for the Registration and Temporary Activities of Representative Offices of Overseas Non-governmental Organizations within the Territory of China (for comment)."

The draft Guidelines are meant to provide more detailed information on the Management Act on Activities of Overseas Non-governmental Organizations within the Territory of the People’s Republic of China[1] (hereafter the Overseas NGO Law) which goes into effect January 1, 2017. The Guidelines are divided into four sections: 1) the procedures and documents required for registering a representative office; 2) the procedures and documents required for filing a record for temporary activities; 3) additional issues; and 4) the required forms.

According to news sources[2], the head of the Overseas NGO Management Office, Hao Yunhong, presented the Guidelines and nine overseas NGOs were invited to present their comments on the draft. (It was not made clear if the draft would be limited to comments from only a small number of overseas NGOs or if there would be a more extensive public comment period.) Mr. Hao noted that the provincial Public Security Bureaus were responsible for registration of representative offices and filing records for temporary activities. The Ministry of Public Security in Beijing would not be directly involved in registration and filing records, but instead would be responsible for providing guidance and coordination for the provincial bureaus. The Shanghai Municipal Public Security Bureau’s Entry/Exit Administration has already set up booths, signs and equipment to receive overseas NGOs, and other provinces and cities are said to be in the process of preparing their own service stations.

Mr. Hao also revealed that the Overseas NGO management service information system and websites were being constructed. Once completed, these online platforms can be used by overseas NGOs to make reservations for registration or filing of records, online application and submission of relevant materials, and the posting of relevant documents. In addition, the Ministry of Public Security and relevant departments have set up a coordinating mechanism for supervision and management of ONGOs, and will be responsible for studying, coordinating and resolving major problems in facilitating the supervision, administration and services to overseas NGOs carrying out activities in mainland China.

Below are a few of my takeaways from reading over the draft Guidelines:

1) There's not that much in the way of additional details in these Guidelines, but mostly a repackaging of what has already been stated in the Overseas NGO Law to make the procedures easier to understand.

2) The “registration and management” department for overseas NGOs seeking to either register a representative office, or “file a record” for temporary activities, is to be the provincial Public Security Bureau where the rep office or activities (or more specifically the Chinese partners coordinating on these activities) are located. This led several overseas NGOs at the Shanghai forum to raise the question of what they should do if they have offices and/or activities in several provinces. Do they need to register in every one of those provinces? It seems one possible solution would be to allow overseas NGOs with offices or activities in multiple provinces to register or file a record at the national-level Ministry of Public Security. But Mr. Hao already made it clear that the Ministry of Public Security would not be directly involved in registration or filing records.

3) The Guidelines use the term “business administration department” (or BAD  - who says the Chinese public security don’t have a sense of humor?) to refer to what I have called the all-important “professional supervisory unit” (PSU).  Overseas NGOs seeking to register a representative office are required to have the approval of a BAD, generally a government or quasi-government agency, before they can even begin to register. In the past, it has been very difficult for overseas NGOs to get the approval of a BAD. The Ministry of Public Security has stated it will release a list of eligible BADs, but it is unclear whether the BADs on this list will be obligated to offer their services to an overseas NGO that approaches them.

4) In the section on Overseas NGOs filing a record for temporary activities, the Guidelines state: “In the case of Overseas NGO temporary activities, the Chinese partners shall apply for review and approval according to state regulations and file the required documents 15 days prior to the temporary activity at the provincial Public Security Bureau’s Administrative Office of Overseas NGO Affairs.” But like the Overseas NGO Law, these Guidelines remain vague on just what kind of approvals and documents need to be obtained and filed by the Chinese partner.




[1] This is the name of the Overseas NGO Law given in the English-language version of the draft Guidelines that were sent to me. It’s not clear why the translators chose to use Act instead of Law which is the more standard translation.
[2] http://news.xinhuanet.com/legal/2016-10/14/c_1119721678.htm http://www.thepaper.cn/newsDetail_forward_1543664