Showing posts with label china foundation center. Show all posts
Showing posts with label china foundation center. Show all posts

Saturday, December 9, 2017

The Charity Law and the mainstreaming of philanthropy and civil society (sort of) in 2016-17, Part 2


In my last post, I mentioned some events and trends that suggest philanthropic and civic activity is slowly entering the mainstream of Chinese society. These are trends that some of us may not want to recognize but we ignore them at our peril. Whether we like it or not, Chinese (and here I mean citizens and non-governmental actors and not just the government) are driving social change. Below are two more trends we should be keeping an eye on.

One is the growing interest of Chinese individuals in giving as evidenced in the rapid rise of online fundraising. In 2016, the Ministry of Civil Affairs approved 13 charitable organizations’ online philanthropy platforms. Among them, the Tencent Philanthropy (腾讯公益平台), Ant Group Philanthropy (蚂蚁金服公益平台) and Taobao Philanthropy (淘宝公益平台) platforms raised 1.289 billion RMB, 37.79% higher than the figure for 2015. Looking at the age groups of the donors, the generation born in the 80s ranked first, making up more than 45% of the donors. Online donations went mostly to education and health, followed by disaster relief and environmental protection. More than 70% of online donations were via mobile phones.

One event that has stimulated a great deal of public interest in philanthropy is Tencent’s 9/9 (September 9th) Day of Giving which began in 2015. This year’s 9/9 Day of Giving (which actually takes place over three days) was the most successful so far, generating over 1.3 billion RMB in donations, of which 829.9 million RMB came from public donations, 299.99 million RMB came from matching funds from the Tencent Foundation, and 177 million RMB from social enterprises.  A total of 12. 68 million donors made contributions to around 6,466 charitable projects.

While the results of the 9/9 Day of Giving are impressive, concerns about fraud have cropped up with reports about a small number of donations being machine-generated. Tencent Foundation has promised to investigate the issue and issue the results soon.

The second trend is the internationalization of Chinese philanthtropy. Over the last few years, largely following the outflow of Chinese investment, Chinese foundations have begun to fund and even set up their own charitable and CSR activities in Southeast Asia, Africa and even Europe, sometimes leveraging the expertise and experience of international NGOs. Until now, however, there has been little connection between Chinese foundation activities abroad and global development goals such as the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). That was the aim of a recent report, “Philanthropy for the SDGs in China,” jointly released by the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) and China Foundation Center (CFC) which are jointly setting up a knowledge sharing platform to mobilize Chinese philanthropic actors to link their activities more closely to the SDGs. One contribution of the report was to call attention to the current imbalances in Chinese philanthropy which has poured funding into education and poverty alleviation, yet neglected areas such as gender equality, sanitation, clean energy and climate change.

As with online fundraising, the internationalization of Chinese philanthropy is going through growing pains. While some Chinese philanthropists and foundations have started to make donations and set up projects overseas, they have done so warily, sensitive to public backlash against Chinese resources being used to support development abroad rather than development at home. One of the first studies of Chinese NGOs internationalizing found that while over half of the NGOs surveyed felt it was necessary to internationalize, only about 17% felt the current environment was right while about 46% felt the environment for internationalization was not sufficiently developed[i]. Still there is no doubt that internationalization is taking off and will gather steam following China’s growing footprint overseas and initiatives like One Belt One Road.  The same study found that the value of overseas donations from Chinese foundations in 2015 had risen by a factor of 3.66 since 2014 and 1209 since 2008.


[i] Deng, Guosheng. 2017. “Trends in Overseas Philanthropy by Chinese Foundations.” Voluntas, (April).

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

The Best and Worst of 2010 for China's NGOs

January 13, 2011

I generally avoid these kinds of lists, but then got emails from two different people in the NGO community, each with their own list of what had happened in 2010 that were complete opposites.  One listed all good things, and the other listed all the bad things.  This led me to construct my own list that seeks to reconcile these very opposite views of what happened in China's civil society sector in 2010.  The reality is that if you combined both of these lists, you wouldn't be far off the mark.  The year 2010 was truly a schizophrenic year for Chinese civil society with rapid progress in the Chinese philanthropic sector, but setbacks for grassroots NGOs in other sectors.  If 2008 was seen by many as the “Year of the NGO” then 2010 could be said to be the “Year of Philanthropy”.  It was (with apologies to Charles Dickens) the “best of times and the worst of times” for China’s civil society. 
Following are some (and I stress “some” because this list is by no means exhaustive) of the best and worst moments of 2010 for China’s civil society.


The Best of 2010

APRIL – after the Yushu earthquake in Qinghai, a number of NGOs participated in the earthquake relief, including NGO networks that had formed in response to the Wenchuan earthquake, as well as new networks.

APRIL – The Green Choice Alliance, a group of 34 grassroots NGOs, among them Friends of Nature, Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs and Green Beagle, released an investigative report on heavy metal pollution from the information and technology sector.  The Alliance is yet another sign of the growth and maturation of China’s civil society networks.

JUNE -- The Beijing Normal University Philanthropy Research Institute was established with funding from Jet Li’s One Foundation.  In a move that signals how much progress civil society has made in China, Wang Zhenyao resigned his post as a government official in the Ministry of Civil Affairs to head the Institute.  The Institute will provide training and counseling to promote professional philanthropic talen in China.

JULY -- The China Foundation Center was established after a decade of effort led by private foundation leaders such as Naruda’s Xu Yongguang.   The CFC is modeled after the U.S. Foundation Center and seeks to strengthen transparency and accountability in China’s foundation sector, and thereby strengthen public trust in philanthropy, by providing a database on foundations' financials, activities, and performance. 

In response to public dissatisfaction with government restrictions on fundraising for the Yushu earthquake (see the Worst of 2010 below), the Ministry of Civil Affairs established a special office to collect public opinions. With more than 420 million internet users and more than 805 mobile phone users in China, this mechanism may be an opportunity for social media to shape policy making in China.

SEPTEMBER -- The Social Innovation Forum in Shanghai—also called the New Philanthropy Carnival—was organized by the China Social Entrepreneur Foundation (or YouChange) to encourage new thinking on addressing China’s social, economic, and environmental challenges. The Shanghai municipal government was one of the first local governments to invest in and support social innovation centers in China.

SEPTEMBER -- Business for Social Responsibility (BSR) launched CiYuan, an initiative that builds innovative, cross-sector partnerships to enhance the value of social investment in China. Working with the Taproot Foundation, BSR will introduce a skills-based volunteerism model in China to leverage corporate human capital to build NGO capacity.

SEPTEMBER --Bill Gates and Warren Buffett held a dialogue with Chinese billionaires about investing their money in philanthropy.  The dialogue generated a nationwide discussion on how China’s growing class of wealthy entrepreneurs in China can make social investments and become strategic philanthropists. 

About this time, news also came out about the Shenzhen experiment to make it easier for NGOs to register.  Jet Li’s One Foundation was able to use the more liberal rules to register as a public foundation (see below).   These experiments have been going on for some time and in different localities for different types of social organizations, and illustrate just how complex and fluid the regulatory environment for nonprofits is in China. 

OCTOBER -- Liu Xiaobo receives the Nobel Peace Prize.

JANUARY 2011  (Ok, technically not a 2010 event but close enough!)  The Jet Li One Foundation was the first private foundation to be legally registered as a public fundraising foundation in Shenzhen— yet another sign that the government is loosening its control over philanthropy.  

The Worst of 2010

FEBRUARY -- the Ministry of Education issued a notice asking all Chinese universities to not work with Oxfam HK and other international NGOs that seek to recruit college volunteers for their projects. 

MARCH (This story did not come out in the media until March, 2010 when these new regulations went into effect but other sources say the regulation was first issued in December of 2009) -- the State Administration of Foreign Exchange issued a new set of regulations that made it more difficult for Chinese enterprises to receive donations from foreign organizations by asking for notarization and additional paperwork.  These regulations have especially made life harder for grassroots NGOs registered as businesses who are receiving funds from international donors.
 

MARCH – Peking University announced that it was disassociating itself from the well-known NGO, Peking University Women’s Legal Aid Center.  The Center continues to operate and has registered as both a law firm and an enterprise.

MARCH -- NGOCN (NGO Development and Exchange Network), a Kunming-based NGO that serves as a information clearinghouse and training center for grassroots NGOs was closed down, supposedly for encouraging NGOs to participate in activities to combat the drought in southwestern China.  It has since reemerged as NGOCN.info.
 

MAY -- Since January 14, 2010, Beijing Aizhixing Institute, one of China’s foremost HIV/AIDS NGOs has been investigated and harassed by numerous government departments, and faced difficulty in getting its funds.  In May, saying he could no longer tolerate the harassment, Wan Yanhai, founder of Beijing Aizhixing, left for the U.S. with his family.

SUMMER – Authorities sought to restrict NGO participation in the Yushu earthquake, asking a network of Qinghai NGOs to disband, and restricting NGOs from fundraising for the earthquake.  The Ministry of Civil Affairs asked 15 national-level foundations to turn the relief funds they had raised over to relevant government agencies so the funds could be better managed.

NOVEMBER – One the eve of World AIDS Day 2010, another AIDS organization, Ai Yuan, “Beijing Loving Source Information Consulting Center" announced that it was closing its doors because of tax audits by Beijing tax authorities.
 

NOVEMBER – Liang Congjie, founder of Friends of Nature and one of the leaders of the first generation of China’s NGO leaders, passed away in Beijing.

DECEMBER – A number of activists who were invited to Oslo for Liu Xiaobo’s Nobel Peace Prize ceremony were not allowed out of the country.

Finally, the Charity Law that was expected to come out this year was held up for further review in the NPC.  Revisions of the registration and management regulations for social organizations continue to be held up as they have for the past few years.

The big question of course is why we’re seeing this schizophrenic pattern in China’s civil society.  I’ll address this question in my next blog. 

Sunday, March 7, 2010

Xu Yongguang's talk at the Foreign Correspondent's Club of China

Below is my translation of Mr. Xu Yongguang's remarks (along with the original Chinese text) at the Foreign Correspondent's Club of China on February 24, 2010.

非公募基金会:改变中国民间公益生态
徐永光

Nonpublic Fundraising (private) Foundations: Changing China’s Nongovernmental, Public Welfare Environment
Xu Yongguang


春节期间,我做了一个梦,梦见财政部和国家税务总局修改了关于非营利组织免税问题的两个政策性文件。这两个文件收紧了国家对非营利组织的税收优惠政策。为此,在2009年12月,24家基金会负责人致函财政部和国家税务总局,要求与财政部长谢旭人和国家税务总局局长肖捷直接对话,并请求国务院对两个文件的合法性进行审查。

During the Spring Festival, I had a dream to modify the two policy documents of the Ministry of Finance and State Administration of Taxation regarding non-profit organization tax exemption. These two documents restrict the state's preferential taxation policies toward nonprofits (NPOs). To this end, in December 2009, 24 Foundations wrote to the Ministry of Finance and State Administration of Taxation, asking for a direct dialogue with Mr. Xie, the Minister of Finance and State Administration of Taxation director, Mr Xiao Jie, and to request the State Council to carry out a review on the two documents.

这个事件,一方面反映了中国非营利组织发展的政策环境还不尽人意,一方面也反映在非营利组织认为自己的权益受到损害时,哪怕这种损害是来自政府部门,也懂得依据法律程序,来维护自己的权力。

This event, on the one hand shows that China's policy environment for NPOs is unsatisfactory. But it also shows that NPOs know how to protect their own rights in accordance with legal procedures when their rights are being infringed, even by government departments.

去年10月,我率中国非公募基金会赴美访问团,在哈佛大学的一次会议上说:“中国经济体制改革30年来,经济迅猛发展,已经成为世界第三大经济体,令世界感到意外。我相信,未来30年,中国的基金会的发展也会让世界感到意外,有可能是美国老大,中国老二”。中国的同行都以为然。

Last year in October, I led a delegation of China's non-public offering foundations to the United States to a meeting at Harvard University, where I said: "China's economic reforms 30 years ago, rapid economic development has become the world's third largest economy, and surprised the world . I believe that over the next 30 years, China's development of its foundations will surprise the world, and even become second only to the U.S. Chinese foundations all believe this.

2004年中国《基金会管理条例》的出台,使中国非公募基金会得以破茧而出。到2009年短短5年间,非公募从无到有,已经注册成立846家,数量直逼已经发展了30年的公募基金会会(991家)。更令人兴奋的是,因为私人财富的迅速增长,中国的巨型私人基金会已经出现。去年,有两位福建籍企业家相继亮相:上半年,福耀玻璃董事长曹德旺宣布要捐出价值40亿人民币的福耀玻璃股票成立以他父亲名字命名的“河仁基金会”,因此引发了捐股能否成立基金会的争论,促使财政部在当年发出了《关于企业公益性捐赠股权有关财务问题的通知》,明确捐股可以捐赠给基金会。下半年,福建富豪陈发树给刚刚成立的新华都基金会捐股票83亿,使这家基金会一夜之间成为中国资产规模最大的基金会。
非公募基金会作为中国“民间慈善崛起的新生代”(人民日报语),对于改变中国民间公益的生态环境具有重要意义。

China’s "Foundation Management Regulations" passed in 2004 was a breakthrough for China's non-public fundraising foundations. By 2009, just five years later, the number of non-public fundraising foundations have gone from 0 to 846, and nearly matched the number of public fundraising foundations that have developed over the last 30-years (991). Even more exciting is that because of the rapid growth of private wealth, large private foundations have emerged in China. Last year, two Fujian entrepreneurs emerged: in the first half of 2009, Fuyao Chairman Cao Dewang announced he would donate 4 billion yuan in Fuyao shares in his father's name to set up the "Heren Foundation," which led to a controversy over whether you could use company shares to establish a foundation. This prompted the Ministry of Finance to issue this year a "Notice on Financial Issues regarding Equity-linked Corporate Charitable Donations", to clarify that shares could be donated to foundations. In the second half of 2009, Fujian Regal Chen Fa Shu donated 8.3 billion yuan in stock to the newly established Xinhuadu Foundation, making that foundation’s assets the largest in China. Non-public fundraising foundations represent the "rise of a new generation of non-governmental charitable initiatives in China" (People's Daily), and is of great significance to changing the environment for China's nongovernmental public welfare sector.

一、 非公募基金会突破了民间组织登记难的制度瓶颈
长期以来,根据民间组织双重管理体制的规定,我国的基金会和慈善组织都带有很强“官办”色彩,只有政府或者其授权的部门才有设立慈善组织的可能。非公募基金会的设立,民政部门既可以做业务管理部门,又是登记注册部门,为企业和企业家回报社会、实现企业社会责任和参与公共事务提供了渠道。换句话说,过去,个人、企业参与公益,只有捐钱的权力,现在有权自己办公益组织了。

我国非公募基金会的发展正处于起飞的初期阶段,可以预期在接下来的10到20年期间还将是设立非公募基金会发展的高潮期。这与世界上各国基金会的发展规律基本吻合。

1. Non-public fundraising foundations have broken through the systemic bottleneck for civil society organization registration.

For a long time, due to the provisions of the dual management system for non-governmental organizations, China's foundations and philanthropic organizations have had a strong government background. Only the government or its authorized departments had the possibility of setting up charitable organizations. For non-public fundraising foundations, the Ministry of Civil Affairs can serve as both the professional supervising agency and the registration agency, in order for enterprises and entrepreneurs to give back to society, and realize corporate social responsibility and provide a channel for participation in public affairs. In other words, in the past, individuals and enterprises only had the power to donate money to participate in public service, now they can establish their own public welfare organizations.

The development of China's non-public fundraising foundations is in the early stages of take-off, and we can expect the next 10 to 20-year period to be the high tide. This will be in line with development of foundations in other countries.

二、 非公募基金会突破了民间慈善资源配置不合理的瓶颈
我国的公募基金会已经有20多年的发展历史。这些基金会的资金筹集、善款使用和日常管理等方方面面,难以脱离政府的控制和影响,民间捐赠的使用往往是从民间流向政府,弥补政府公共财政投入的不足。这既与政府职能转变的改革大势不符,也抑制了民间慈善力量的生长发育。中国非营利组织的增加值和就业人数,在服务业中所占比例大约都只占0.3%,与世界平均水平相差甚远,民间公益服务机构获取资源难是一个重要原因。这是中国民间组织继登记注册难之后的第二个制度瓶颈。

2. Non-public fundraising foundations have broken through the irrational bottleneck blocking the allocation of resources for nongovernmental charitable foundations.

Public fundraising foundations have a history of more than 20 years in China. The public foundation's fund-raising, donations, daily management, etc., are not easily separated from government control. And the use of private donations often gets diverted from the people to the government, in order to make up shortfalls in the government’s budget. This trend does not conform with the reform of government functions, and inhibits the growth and development of non-governmental charitable efforts. Chinese non-profit organizations represent only about 0.3% of the service industry in terms of value-added and employment. This is a far cry from the world average. Non-governmental public welfare organizations’ difficulty in getting access to resources is an important reason. But the most important reason has to do with the difficulty of registering non-governmental organizations.

非公募基金会可以自主地确定自己的公益项目和资助方向,慈善资源可以流向政府系统之外的民间公益服务领域,成为民间公益服务机构(俗称草根组织)的重要资源提供者,再造公益产业链,这将从根本上改善民间公益发展的生态环境。
在2008年汶川地震发生后,非公募基金会反映迅速,成为草根组织迅速投入抗震救灾和灾后重建的重要资金提供者。如我所在的南都基金会,就资助了60多家草根组织的灾后重建项目。

Non-public fundraising foundations have the autonomy to determine the direction of their public welfare projects and funding. Charitable resources can flow towards public service areas outside of the government system, and turn into an important resource provider for non-governmental public welfare organizations (commonly known as grass-roots organizations). This will fundamentally improve the environment for the development of non-governmental public welfare.

After the Wenchuan earthquake in 2008, non-public fundraising foundations rapid response became a major provider of funds for grassroots organizations’ rapid involvement in the earthquake relief and reconstruction. For example, Nandu Foundation which I work for, has funded more than 60 grass-roots organizations engaged in post-disaster reconstruction projects.


三、非公募基金会突破了民间组织独立性和治理难的制度瓶颈
非公募基金会出现之前,从政府部门脱胎出来的公募基金会因其与政府之间存在千丝万缕的联系,难以保持其自身的独立性。非公募基金会与政府之间没有财产上的纠葛,也无人事上的交错,具有独立于政府的人格,为确保其独立性并实现以理事会为决策核心的有效治理提供了制度保证。

3. Non-public fundraising foundations have broken the systemic bottleneck restricting the independence and governance of civil society organizations.

Before the advent of non-public fundraising foundations, public fundraising foundations that emerged out of government departments, had a hard time asserting their own independence because of the inextricable link that exists the government and these foundations. Nonpublic fundraising foundations do not share property or personnel with the government and thus are more independent of government.


四、 非公募基金会突破了民间组织人才严重匮乏的瓶颈
以往中国非营利组织从业者主要是两部分人,一是原来的政府工作人员或退休干部,二是追求社会理想的知识分子,缺少有经营管理能力的专业人才。非公募基金会使大量熟谙现代公司治理和市场管理专业的人士投身公益领域,同时,非公募基金会可以以接近于市场的薪酬待遇吸引年轻专业人才,对改善非营利部门的人才结构产生了重大影响。
非公募基金会的成长对于中国公民社会的培育和发展具有举足轻重的影响。在大发展中要避免大混乱,这是业内同仁的共识。为此,2009年中国非公募基金会发展论坛发布了《非公募基金会自律宣言》。今年1月,30多家非公募基金会和公募基金会联合发起创建中国基金会中心,让基金会自律从信息透明开始,通过提高基金会的透明度、公信力,通过提升基金会行业的自律、自治、自我规范和自我服务的能力,来引领中国整个民间公益行业的健康发展。

4. Nonpublic fundraising foundations are breaking through the bottleneck of lack of capable practitioners in civil society organizations.

In the past, practitioners in China’s non-profit organizations were mainly of two kinds. One was former government staff or retired cadres. The second was intellectuals in the the pursuit of social ideals. What was lacking was professionals with management capacity. Nonpublic fundraising foundations have brought into the public arena a large number of such professionals who are well versed in modern corporate governance and market regulation. At the same time, non-public fundraising foundations can offer salaries that come closer to compensation packages that attract young professionals, and can have a major impact on improving the personnel structure of the non-profit sector.

The growth of nonpublic fundraising foundations has had a significant impact in fostering China’s civil society. In the large-scale development to avoid chaos, this is the consensus of colleagues in the industry. To this end, in 2009, China's non-public fundraising foundations Development Forum issued the "Declaration of self-discipline for non-public fundraising foundation." In January of this year, more than 30 non-public fundraising foundations and public fundraising foundations joined together to found the China Foundation Center, to encourage foundations to start disciplining themselves through information transparency, thereby improving the transparency and credibility of foundations, and improving the discipline, governance, standardization and service of foundations, so that we can look forward to the healthy development of China’s nongovernmental public welfare sector.